Roosevelt's New Deal

IV. Roosevelt's Administration - Domestic Issues - New Deal
A. Phase I - 1933-34

Initial Actions of Roosevelt's First Administration
a. Inauguration - FDR was sworn in as 32d US President on 4 March 1933.
(1) With no blueprint of what to do concerning the growing economic crisis, he did not know for certain what would or would not work.
(2) He had tried many innovative things while Governor of NY.
(3) He manifested a flexible, pragmatic approach to meet the economic crisis, and brought with him his NY "Braintrust."
b. After many serious runs on banks, FDR declared a 4-day banking holiday 5-9 Mar.
(1) From 1930 to FDR's inauguration, 5,504 banks closed with deposits totaling almost $3.5 billion.
(2) An embargo on the exportation of gold, silver and currency was also put into place, without a license from the Treasury Dept.
Hundred Days - 9 March -16 June 1933
a. Introduction
(1) With strong majorities in both Houses of Congress, a special session of the 73d Congress began on 9 March, at first focusing on immediate relief.
(2) What emerged was a 3-fold focus -- Relief - Recovery - Reform
(3) First action of the special session -- Emergency Banking Relief Act - 9 Mar 1933
(a) The President was given broad powers over credit transactions and over transactions in currency, gold, silver and foreign currency.
(b) Gold hoarding and exportation of gold was prohibited (10-year sentence + $10,000 fine) as the US was taken off the gold standard for its currency.
(c) Banks could reopen on 10 March if they could prove solvency.
(d) By 12 March, 1000 banks reopened, and the money panic subsided
(e) Within two weeks, stocks rose 15% as hoarded currency was returned to the banks, and gold and gold certificates were returned to the Treasury.
(4) 12 March - FDR's first fireside chats -- "we only had fear to fear"
b. Relief Actions
(1) Federal Emergency Relief Act - 12 May 1933
(a) It established the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA ) and appropriated $500 million for quick relief with 1/2 given immediately as direct relief
(b) It matched $1 for every $3 to states with their own relief programs.
(c) Harry Hopkins was appointed as the Federal Relief Administrator.
(2) Reforestation Relief Act - 31 March 1933
(a) It created the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) with 250,000 immediate jobs for men aged 18-25 at $30 per month with as much as $25 being sent home
(b) Members were supplied with food, shelter, transportation, clothing, medical care and some education or training.
(c) Projects included reforestation, road construction, soil erosion and flood control, and development of national parks, although critics claimed this was "make work."
(d) By its end in 1941, 21/2 million men had worked in 1,500 CCC camps.
c. Recovery Actions
(1) Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA ) 12 May 1933
(a) The dramatic reduction in farm prices from 1929-32 led to a farmer's strike (summer 1932) led by Milo Reno (IA) and Farmers' Holiday Assoc.
(b) It was designed to restore purchasing power of agricultural producers by cutting production eliminating surplus crops of basic commodities and establishing parity prices
(c) It established the subsidy principle whereby, for voluntary reduction of acreage in production, farmers were paid direct benefits or rental payments.
(d) It authorized the president to inflate the currency by devaluating its gold content or the free coinage of silver and issue $3 billion in paper currency.
(e) It also provided funds for loans to farmers to meet their mortgage payments. Farm Credit Act - 16 June 1933
(f) Payments for these programs would come from a production tax on the processors of certain farm commodities.
(g) The processors tax (and the AAA itself funded by the tax) was struck down by the US Supreme Court - US vs Butler 19369
(2) National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA ) 16 June 1933
(a) The NIRA was designed to balance the interests of business and labor and consumers and to reduce unemployment.
i) For codes of fair competition, anti-trust laws were suspended.
ii) Section 7(a) guaranteed workers the right to collective bargaining.
iii) It established minimum wage and maximum hour laws.
(b) Hugh S. Johnson directed the National Recovery Administration, whose symbol was the blue eagle and its motto "We Do Our Part ."
(c) It also established the Public Works Administration (PWA) which supervised the building of roads, public buildings and other projects, funded with $3.3 billion
i) Secretary of the Interior Harold Ickes was appointed Director.
ii) Among the projects were the Grand Coulee Dam, NY's Triborough Bridge and almost 3/4 of the nation's new schools.
(d) Supreme Court struck down parts - Schechter Poultry vs US 1935
d. Reform Actions
(1) Tennessee Valley Authority - TVA - 18 May 1933
(a) Munitions plants on the TN River in Alabama and a large hydroelectric power plant built by the government in WWI were still in government hands, but the government wanted to dispose of these to private interests.
(b) Legislative attempts of Sen. George Norris (NE) to continue the federal operation at Muscle Shoals failed under Coolidge and Hoover.
(c) Under FDR, Tennessee Valley Authority was created and all government-owned property at Muscle Shoals was transferred to the Authority, governed by a three-man board.
i) The Authority was charged with building dams, generating and selling electricity, manufacturing and selling fertilizers produced, establishing flood control and developing navigation.
ii) Six dams were completed before World War II.
(d) Critics charged that it was unfair competition with private companies supplying electricity in the area. (TN, N.C. KY, VA, MS, GA)
(e) Unfortunately it was the only such project developed domestically.
(2) Federal Securities Act - 27 May 1933
(a) It required the Federal Government to register and approve all issues of stocks and bonds and issuers to make full disclosure all pertinent information about an issuing company.
(b) On 6 June 1936, some of its duties were assumed by the Securities Exchange Act which created the Securities and Exchange Commission
i) It regulates exchanges and transactions involving securities.
ii) Joseph P. Kennedy was the first chairman of the SEC.
(3) Home Owners Refinancing Act (16 June 1933) established the Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC) to provide mortgage money and other aid such as taxes, and money for repairs, aiding over 1 million homeowners when dismantled in 1936.
(4) Banking (Glass-Steagall) Act of 1933 - 16 June 1933
(a) It created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC ) empowered to guarantee individual bank deposits up to $5000.
(b) It permitted branch banking, allowed savings and industrial banks to be members of the Federal Reserve System and separated commercial banking from investment banking thus eliminating excessive speculation with depositor's funds.
e. Conclusion
(1) The Hundred Days laid the foundation for the New Deal.
(2) Although not solving many problems of the Depression, the nation definitely had turned around and people were more confident about their government.

Civil Works Administration (CWA ) 8 November 1933 created by executive order
a. In the winter of 1933-34, FDR created the CWA to provide temporary jobs.
b. Some 4 million were employed raking leaves, shoveling snow, and working in national parks, which critics again complained was "make work."
c. Harry Hopkins directed this agency, ceasing Mar 1934 after spending $740 million.
Gold Reserve Act - 30 January 1934
a. All gold in the Federal Reserve banks was transferred to the National Treasury.
b. FDR was empowered to fix the value of the US dollar between 50-60 in terms of gold.
c. 31 January - he set the price of gold at $35 an ounce and the dollar at 59.06 .
Communications Act - 19 June 1934 - established the Federal Communications Commission (FCC ) to supervise radio, telegraph, and telephone communications.
Silver Purchase Act - 19 June 1934 - empowered FDR to increase the Treasury's silver holdings to 1/3 the value of gold, nationalizing silver stocks and purchases (victory for Free Silverites)
Firsts for Women - Roosevelt Appointees
a. Cabinet Member - Frances Perkins (l880-l965),Secretary of Labor to 1945.
b. Director of the Mint - Nettie T. Ross , previously elected first woman Governor
c. Ambassador - Ruth Bryan Owen - Denmark 1933-36.
Other Events in 1934
a. The Gross National Debt was $34 billion
b. 22 July - John Dillinger, Public Enemy # One, shot by the FBI near a Chicago Theatre
c. Life Magazine began.

Those Who Thought the New Deal Had Gone Too Far
a. Conservative Dissatisfaction
(1) Liberty League , established in August 1934, was composed of financiers, indus-trialists, corporation lawyers, conservative Democrats, and others.
(2) It attacked the New Deal as a dangerous Constitutional departure and actively opposed measures like the Wagner-Connery Labor Relations (National Labor Relations) Act and the Wealth Tax (Revenue Act of 1935).
b. American Socialist Movement
(1) The Socialist Movement fell apart after World War I.
(2) Two US communist parties merged into the Communist Party USA (CPUSA)
(3) Growing by the mid-1930s, it was never more than 10,000 strong, mostly among journalists, writers and labor leaders.
(4) At first highly critical of the New Deal as an attempt to salvage the US capitalist system, it gradually changed its image in the US by denying its own revolutionary doctrine.
(a) As world communism became more conciliatory, it focused on programs, not revolution.
(b) As diplomatic relations were established between the US and the USSR in 1933, the CPUSA worked to establish trade relations between both nations.
(5) Its well-disciplined membership was effective esp. within the labor movement
(6) Because the depression did not create within the American worker a desire to change the US system beyond recognition -- only a refinement of the system -- the socialists did not attract millions of US workers as elsewhere.
Those Who Thought That the New Deal Had Not Gone Far Enough
a. Dr. Francis Townsend -- Old Age Revolving Pension Plan
(1) He called for payments of $200 per month to persons over 60 years of age, to be paid for by a 2% tax on all commercial transactions.
(2) Each recipient would have to spend it all within the month.
(3) By 1935, they claimed 5 million backers, illustrating a desire for a kind of old age pension.
b. Rev. Charles E. Coughlin and the National Union for Social Justice
(1) The Jesuit priest, Charles Coughlin, lived in Royal Oak MI and in 1930, began a radio broadcast in Detroit, which eventually claimed almost 40 million hearers
(2) At first an enthusiastic supporter of the New Deal, but by 1934, he voiced the opinion that FDR was not going far enough.
(3) He was specific in calling for silver inflation, but was extremely vague on other issues, offering no real solutions.
(4) His broadcasts attacked international bankers, Communists, labor unions, and Roosevelt's administration, as unemployment remained high.
(5) By 1937, however, he increasingly voiced anti-semitic and pro-Fascist views, which lost him his relevancy and his huge audience.
(6) His superiors silenced him in 1942.
c. Senator Huey P. Long (1893-1935) and the Share Our Wealth Movement
(1) Huey Long (LA) demanded that the government make Everyman a King
(a) Guarantee every family an annual income of $2,000 and a homestead or $6000 to build a home
(b) To pay for this, the government would nationalize all banks and allow no one to be over a "ten millionaire."
(c) Clubs sprang up across the country, especially in the South, supporting the Share Our Wealth concept.
(2) In August 1935, Long announced his intentions to run for President
(a) If not as the Democratic nominee, then as a third party candidate.
(b) Roosevelt was certain that such a candidacy would pull votes from his campaign for reelection in 1936.
(3) 8 September - Long was shot at the Capital building in Baton Rouge, dying of internal bleeding on 10 September 1935.
(a) His alleged assailant, Dr. Carl Austin Weiss Jr whose father-in-law had been ruined by Long, was immediately killed by Long's bodyguards.
(b) It is believed today that Long's bodyguards accidentally shot him
(4) Rev. Gerald L.K. Smith attempted to keep the Share-Our-Wealth Clubs operative after Long's death, but the movement was never the same.

Roosevelt's Annual Address to Congress - 4 January 1935
a. Roosevelt outlined phase two of the New Deal, establishing the modern welfare system.
(1) The federal government would withdraw from direct relief leaving it to state and local governments, although some national works program would continue to absorb the unemployed.
(2) A program of social reforms included social security for the aged, unemployed and ill, and slum clearance and better housing
(3) Better tax reform
b. The chief beneficiaries of phase two were small farmers and laborers.
Emergency Relief Appropriation Act - 8 April 1935
a. Roosevelt was granted new powers to create agencies to employ millions not yet absorbed into the private sector
b. By Executive Order, he created three additional relief agencies in 1935:
(1) Works Progress Administration (WPA ) May 6 Harry Hopkins admin
(a) The WPA spent $11 billion, and employed over 81/2 million in over 1,410,000 projects between 1935 and its termination on 30 June 1943.
(b) Projects involved manual labor to build public buildings, schools, airfields, parks and post offices, but many projects involved writers, artists, scholars, musicians and actors.
i. Federal Theater Project was created in 1936.
ii) Federal Art Project employed 5,000 in 44 states.
(c) While most critics charged that the WPA was inefficient, wasteful and politically corrupt, it did increase the national purchasing power.
(d) In 1939, the WPA, aka Works Project Administration, was the most serious attempt at relief in Phase Two.
(2) Resettlement Administration (RA ) 1 May Rexford G. Tugwell , admin
(a) Its goals were to improve the condition of farm families not benefiting from the AAA, prevent waste by unprofitable farming operations or improper land use and projects such as reforestation and flood control.
(b) Farm families whose land was unproductive because of the extended drought, esp. in Ark and OK, were relocated to more productive land (about 4500 farm families).
(c) This agency also resettled destitute families in subsistence homestead communities, constructing new suburbs for poor city workers
i) Low income city workers were relocated in "Greenbelt Towns."
ii) Three such communities -- Greenbelt near Washington D.C. Greenhills near Cincinnati Ohio; Greendale near Milwaukee, WI
(3) Rural Electrification Administration (REA ) 11 May
(a) Its goals were to provide electricity to isolated rural areas, where it was not feasible to provide service by private utility companies.
(b) The REA made low interest, long-term loans for the entire cost of constructing light plants and power lines into such isolated areas.
Additional Reform Efforts 1935
a. National Labor Relations (Wagner-Connery ) Act 5 July
(1) Established the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB)
(2) Section 7 guaranteed employees could join labor unions and bargain collectively through labor representatives.
(3) Section 8 defined unfair practices on the part of the employer.
(4) Most importantly, it compelled employers to recognize a union if over 50% of the employees joined the union.
(5) The Supreme Court upheld it on 12 April 1937
(a) One week after Roosevelt unveiled his "courtpacking" plan, two justices switched their opinion from the earlier Schecter case.
(b) National Labor Relations Board vs Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp 5 to 4 guaranteed worker rights to unionize.
b. Social Security Act - 14 August 1935
(1) Partially as the result of the Townsend-Long proposals, the act established a coopera-tive federal-state system of unemployment compensation by levying a federal tax on total payrolls of those employing eight or more persons (1% in 1936, 2% in 1937, 3% thereafter)
(2) It levied a tax (1% in 1937) equally between employee and employer to provide for old-age pensions for retirees in January 1942, receiving monthly checks between $10-85.
(3) For persons already retired, the federal government shared the costs with states ($15 per month matching funds plus some aid for administrative costs).
(4) Grants were provided for financial aid for the blind, homeless, crippled and dependent children, and some services such as maternity and infant care.
(5) The Supreme Court upheld it - 24 May 1937
(a) Steward Machine Co vs Davis - 5 to 4 - unemployment compensation
(b) Helvering vs Davis - 7 to 2 - old age benefits provisions
c. National Housing (Wagner-Steagall ) Act - 1 September 1937 - created the US Housing Authority (USHA) to administer low-interest 60-year loans to small communities for slum clearance and construction projects and to grant subsidies for setting rent geared to low-income levels in areas where local agencies provided 25% of the federal grant.
d. Public Utility Holding Company (Wheeler-Rayburn) Act 28 August
(1) Following the collapse of the financial empire of Samuel Insull , a number of utility companies were threatened with bankruptcy.
(2) Congress limited the possibility of controlling companies with a small amount of capital and prevented the type of pyramiding which Insull had done, creating several layers into a super corporation that was only a holding company.
(3) Electric and gas holding companies were restricted to a single and concentrated system in a single location.
(4) Roosevelt likened this pyramid to a "96-inch dog being wagged by a 4-inch tail"
Revenue Act of 1935 (Wealth Tax Act ) - 30 August - particularly irksome to wealthy conservatives
a. Increased the surtax rate on individual incomes over $50,000, the estate tax on individual estates over $40,000 and graduated steeply taxes on individual incomes over $1 million until the rate was 75% in excess of $5 million.
b. Decreased the small corporation tax rate to 12% while increasing the corporate tax, on incomes above $15,000 to 15%.
c. Some excess profits over 10% were taxed at a 6% rate and in excess of 15% at a 12% rate.
Additional events in 1935
a. 9 November - The AF of L created an industrial union, the Committee for Industrial Organization (CIO ), to organize other workers not covered by the AF of L.
(1) United Mine Workers president John L Lewis was the chairman.
(2) Continued challenges to AF of L conservative leadership resulted in expulsion in 1937 after which it reorganized into Congress of Industrial Organizations
b. 5 Dec 1955 - AF of L and CIO combined with George Meany elected president.

Election of 1936
a. Candidates
(1) Standing on the Administration's record, Democrats in Philadelphia, no longer plagued by the 2/3 rule (abolished in 1932), renominated Roosevelt and Garner by acclamation for a 2nd term, although neither faced oppositon from within the party.
(2) Republicans in Cleveland nominated for President the only Republican to win aa governor in 1934, Alf Landon (KS) and Col Frank Knox (IL), for Veep
(a) Their platform condemned the New Deal, accused Roosevelt of taking over the powers of Congress, of passing unconstitutional laws and of reckless "deficit" spending (calling him Franklin "Deficit" Roosevelt), and called for the return of relief administration to local nonpolitical agencies, a balanced budget, no more devaluation of the dollar, a revision of personal and corporate taxes and the right of labor to bargain collectively.
(b) Many conservative Democrats supported the Republican candidate, including Alfred E. Smith and others active in the Liberty League
b. Campaign
(1) A bitterly fought campaign was waged against the New Deal, condemning it as a planned, bureaucratic economy, wasteful, radical, experimental and confusing, aided by almost 80% of the nation's newspapers which endorsed Landon.
(2) Campaign slogans that emerged: Let's Get Another Deal ; Life, Liberty, and Landon ; Defeat the New Deal and its Reckless Spending
(3) After an unscientific telephone survey (only the super rich had phones), which overwhelmingly chose Landon, the slogan Make It A Landon-slide emerged.
c. Results
(1) Roosevelt received 27,751,612 popular (523 electoral) votes to Landon's 16,681,913 popular (8 electoral) votes, carrying only Maine and Vermont.
(2) Democrats carried over 2/3 of both Houses of Congress (Senate 76 - 16, gaining seven, 4 to minor parties; House 331 - 89, 13 to minor parties).
Supreme Court
a. During Roosevelt's first term, the Supreme Court struck down as unconstitutional major pieces of New Deal Legislation.
(1) Schechter vs US 1935 declared the NIRA unconstitutional because Congress had no control over intrastate commerce (Schechter Company operated only in NY)
(2) Butler vs US 1936 declared the AAA's processor's tax unconstitutional.
b. 5 Feb 1937 - Roosevelt, determined to halt this continued threat to his New Deal, introduced the Judiciary Reorganization Bill
(1) It proposed to add judges at all levels of the federal courts, assign judges to the more congested courts and adopt procedures to expedite the appeals process by sending lower court cases on constitutional matters directly to the Supreme Court
(2) Its main purpose, however, was to add justices to the Supreme Court
(a) Justices of the Supreme Court who reached age 70 could retire
(b) When a Supreme Court justice, age 70, did not retire, FDR could add an additional judge up to 6, potentially increasing the court to 15 members.
c. A serious debate erupted
(1) Roosevelt was accused of attempting to upset the balance of powers which existed in the US system, by "packing" the court.
(2) Many desired such changes to be put into a constitutional amendment
(3) The bill reached a serious impasse in Congress in 2 months, dividing Democrats
(4) As the opposition mounted a serious attack against the bill, Roosevelt countered that six old men should not erode the people's wishes and that he was instead trying to restore the balance of power between the three branches of government
d. Several things happened which lessened the urgency of the bill
(1) Supreme Court Retirement Act 1 March 1937 permitted Supreme Court Justices to retire at age 70 with full pay, after 10 years of service
(a) Justice Willis Van Devanter, New Deal opponent, announced his retirement for 18 May, and was replaced by Senator Hugo Black, New Deal supporter, although his confirmation bogged down when it was revealed that he had been a member of the KKK in his youth.
(b) Roosevelt filled seven positions in the next four years, including Louis D. Brandeis who at age 82, retired 13 February 1939
(2) Several New Deal acts were upheld by the Supreme Court (as noted above)
(a) 12 April 1937 - by a 5-4 vote, the NLRA Act was upheld
(b) 24 May - The Social Security Act was upheld.
(3) 26 August 1937 - Judicial Procedure Reform Act revised the lower courts as needed without providing for new judges or justices.
(4) 14 July - when the major proponent of the measure, Senator Joseph T. Robinson (AR) , died the bill died in committee.
e. Results
(1) The rift among Democrats over the issue was never fully resolved, as was apparent in the Bi-Elections of 1938, when Republicans gained seats in Congress for the first time since 1928.
(2) Conservative Democrats and Republicans combined in Congress to slow or halt further New Deal legislation.

Federal relief declined from 3,184,000 to 2,122,960 by 1938.
Revenue Bill extended tax cuts to corporations because of the lingering recession.
Second Agricultural Adjustment Act - 16 February
a. Reestablished the "parity payment" principle.
b. Established the Federal Crop Insurance Corporation (FCIC) within the Department of Agriculture to insure wheat crops only beginning in 1939.
c. The financing would be provided by the Federal Government, not a processor's tax.
Fair Labor Standards (Wages and Hour ) Act 25 June
a. Businesses engaged in interstate commerce (with some exceptions) were required to pay a minimum wage of 40 cents per hour (up from 25 cents).
(1) It increased to 75 @ hour in 1949 and through 1981, 13 times to $3.35 hour
(2) In 1967, farm workers were included at $1.00 per hour.
b. The work week was limited to 44 hours per week without overtime, beginning in 1938 and later trimmed to 40 hours per week by October 1940.
c. Children under 16 were not allowed to work; where hazardous, the age limit was 18.
d. 3 Feb 1941 - The Supreme Court upheld it - US vs Darby Lumber Co

The New Deal had reached its ideological limits in 1938 and Congress had grown conservative as many Democrats abandoned their enthusiasm for FDR's ideas after the "Courtpacking" incident.
Increasingly, however, Roosevelt focused on events in Europe and Asia.